Theme
9:13am June 20, 2014

andromedalogic:

there’s something about the ethical landscape of star trek — not in every episode, but in its overall tendencies — that makes me feel very safe there, very stabilized, in a way that i am not by most moral structures

and i think what it is

is that star trek is pretty firmly, almost without variation, anti-institution.

it starts out that way, with ‘the cage’.

it’s got a pretty strong anti-utilitarian bent throughout — values human autonomy (dignity of risk, heh) over safety — there’s obviously the federation’s troubling paternalism but

i just get this impression from star trek. half its plots can be likened to ‘the ones who walk away from omelas’.

every time a place is Safe, and Happy, and Protects its Inhabitants, that place is dangerous.

every damn time.

star trek knows to trust my instincts even when i don’t.

Notes:
  1. agentleavens reblogged this from neuroflux
  2. teamroquette reblogged this from neednothavehappenedtobetrue
  3. screamingaboutstartrek reblogged this from neuroflux
  4. neuroflux reblogged this from neednothavehappenedtobetrue
  5. neednothavehappenedtobetrue reblogged this from andromedalogic
  6. see-how-tame-i-can-be reblogged this from andromedalogic
  7. achildofawanderingkind reblogged this from epostfix
  8. epostfix reblogged this from tetraghost
  9. another-normal-anomaly reblogged this from gruntledandhinged
  10. thread-of-fire reblogged this from gruntledandhinged and added:
    Indeed, Desire Utilitarianism seems to be the moral theory which is closest to being true (see section titled “Breaking...
  11. gruntledandhinged reblogged this from somervta
  12. dataandphilosophy reblogged this from ozymandias271 and added:
    Yes, there are lots of good reasons to be anti-capitalist. I am maybe slightly excessively annoyed at people who say...
  13. ozymandias271 reblogged this from dataandphilosophy and added:
    Perhaps the person values equality over efficiency and/or believes that we can move into a post-capitalist society that...
  14. estelendur reblogged this from andromedalogic
  15. somervta reblogged this from ozymandias271 and added:
    I’d point out that people like (for example) Peter Singer who have these sort of views towards the disabled have them...
  16. stillwaitingforaliens reblogged this from fizzygingr and added:
    No, it’s the one where, a few years previous, a planetary governor killed off large groups of people because the colony...
  17. dusty-soul reblogged this from withasmoothroundstone
  18. mid-childan-puella-magi reblogged this from withasmoothroundstone
  19. sequintial reblogged this from withasmoothroundstone
  20. chamomile-geode reblogged this from ozymandias271 and added:
    I think maybe the bad, hurtful utilitarians are the ones who have little epistemic humility–the skill of believing there...